Free Rental Analysis
Call us today!

Enter your rental property address below to get your free rental analysis.

Casselberry Property Management

Let us manage your Casselberry rental property

Custom dividing line

Legends Realty wants to give you peace of mind, representing you as the property owner. Our property management services in Casselberry are all-inclusive, so you can maintain your rental property with confidence. We take care of the responsibilities that come up every day, with everything from rent collection to tenant selection and more.

Whether you are overseas or based in Florida, you'll want to make the most out of your real estate investment. You may have plans to purchase an investment property, or already own a home or condo to rent out to tenants. Either way, Legends Realty can help you maximize your returns - offering a mix of investment and property management in Casselberry to address every possible circumstance on your behalf.

Here’s how we can help

  1. Experience on your side
    Our experienced Casselberry property management team sees hundreds of rental applications and are experienced at screening tenants, reference checking and reviewing rental history to ensure you receive high quality tenants.
  2. Avoid unpleasant confrontations
    We are a buffer between you and the tenant - our property managers will help deal with problems such as late payments through to damaged property.
  3. Tenants have someone to talk to right away
    If an issue happens with the property, our property managers are more accessible to address problems at all hours of the day. Our negotiating power with licensed and insured vendors ensure you get the best price on all maintenance jobs.
  4. Decrease tenant turn over
    We know how to keep tenants happy and happy tenants are more likely to want to stay and renew their lease.
  5. On time rent
    Our property managers will work to ensure your tenants pay their rent on time. Consistent rent collection is the key to receiving rent payments on time and they will enforce lease policies if payments aren’t received.
  6. Less stress
    When you let someone else manage both your property and your tenants, you don’t have to worry. Property management takes care of everything for you.
  7. Strict legislative requirements
    Private owners are bound by the same legislative requirements as property managers in their dealings with tenants. This means that if you are taking the task on yourself, you will need to stay up to date with constantly-changing legal requirements. Choosing Legends Realty to manage your investment property is a wise decision that may save you time and money over the long term.
  8. Reduce your Risk
    By hiring Legends Realty you reduce the chance of having a vacant property therefore lowering your risk of lost income. Let us take care of your Casselberry property management needs.

Call today and let us turn your property into a profitable investment for you. Our direct line is 407-333-1010 ext 2

If you are in the market to purchase or sell investment properties please contact our partner Dan Lopez at 407-333-1010 ext 129 E-mail: Website:

Please take a moment to see what others are saying about Legends Realty.

Inquire about Our Services

What Will My Property Rent For?

Property Owners - Please complete the above form for a Free Rental Analysis of your home. Our office will forward to you all the necessary documents for your review, will prepare a rental range and one of our Business Developers will contact you for an appointment to view your property. We specialize in the areas of Seminole, Orange and West Volusia counties of Central Florida.

CENTRAL FLORIDA PROPERTY MANAGEMENT in Lake Mary, Deltona, DeBary, Casselberry, Orlando, Longwood, Winter Springs, Oviedo, Sanford, Maitland, Altamonte Springs, Winter Park, Heathrow, Winter Garden, Windermere, Lake Nona, Orange City, Deland, and Apopka, Florida.

For our procedures and more information, visit our FREE Rental Analysis Blog.


High Quality Marketing -

We have a nationwide marketing strategy. When we enter your property into the Orlando Multiple Listing Service (MLS), over 10,000 Realtors can see your home. We also post your listing online with photos, maps and relevant property details. All of our listings are also available to Lease Locator companies in Florida. Referrals from current and past tenants and other agents we work with also provide us with a great pool of potential tenants.

Marketing strategy of your rental home begins with proper pricing. Even a nicely maintained home will experience difficulties renting if it's priced too high for the current market conditions. We complete a rental analysis and ensure the home is ready to show. We pay attention to details such as, curb appeal and cleanliness of the interior of the property. These few details ensures your home is rented quickly to a very qualified tenant.

Advertising -

We created an aggressive marketing campaign using the latest technology and online resources to attract prospective tenants. Our ads are individually designed for each property to create a professional look and highlight the special features of your property.

Our web-based marketing includes more than 100 websites such as:

  • MLS

  • Hot Pads
  • Google
  • Rental Home Plus
  • My New Place

  • Craigslist
  • Rental
  • Yahoo
  • plus many more!

schedule showings

Showings -

You won't find another management company that is more available to show properties. We have staff available to answer the phone and schedule showings on the weekends, holidays, and evening hours; this is when renters are looking! LOW VACANCY RATE - We can typically get most properties rented within 2 to 5 weeks on average. Our Leasing Consultants send Weekly emailed communication updates while property is vacant. 

Tenant Screening -

Thorough tenant screening is critical to a landlord’s success and we do a number of things to screen tenants.

  1. In our residential verification, we talk to past landlords and ask detailed, open-ended questions about the tenant.
  2. When a private individual instead of a management company is listed as a previous or current landlord, we do a property tax search to confirm we’re talking to the person who actually owns the property. This stops people from trying to commit fraud and our extra level of scrutiny has saved our owners from some potentially bad tenant situations.
  3. We analyze credit reports to get an accurate financial picture and evaluate a tenant’s ability to meet their obligations. Applicants must meet our established credit standards. We pull driver’s license records to check previous addresses. If an applicant says they have been living at one address for three years, but we find they renewed their driver’s license at a different address a year ago, we wonder what they’re trying to hide.
  4. Employment and income verification is also an important part of our screening process. We contact employers to verify employment and income. It’s required that a tenant earns at least three times the monthly rent in order to qualify, and we ask for pay stubs to document the income. If someone is self-employed or retired, we can verify income other ways. 
  5. A thorough background check is critical in the tenant selection process. We look for bankruptcy, foreclosures, evictions, repossessions, convictions.
  6. Finally, we conduct additional searches that reveal any criminal background or other red flags (check writing ability and social security fraud alerts and so much more).

We don’t let tenants move in with pets unless our property owners allow it. Lots of potential tenants have pets, so if you decide to allow them, we protect your property by limiting the breeds we’ll accept as well as the quantity and size of the animals. Pet owners are subject to extra screening and lease addenda.


Lease -

We handle all the necessary paperwork associated with the leasing of your property and ensure compliance with applicable local, state and federal laws. Our lease is attorney drawn and is updated and reviewed by an attorney regularly. We enforce all the terms of the lease including timely rent collection and the tenant's responsibilities to maintain the property. 

Maintain Consistent Policies with Your Tenants -

Keeping your relationship strictly professional and allowing your property manager to enforce your lease will help you be a more successful landlord. If rent begins to come in late or not at all, you don’t want to let your tenant get away with it. Even if you are emotionally moved by the tenant’s situation, you need to think about your property as an income producing business.

tenant policies

Scheduled Property Reviews -

Our maintenance staff visit the property on a regular basis to perform bi-annual property reviews. The visits include a full walk-thru of the interior and exterior of the property along with digital pictures and a written report. Frequent visits help to discover tenant damage or neglect, maintenance concerns, unauthorized pets, over occupancy issues, etc, early in the term of the lease.

Move-out Process -

We set high expectations for our tenants from the beginning of the lease period. Tenants are supplied with written move-out procedures to follow and are held accountable for any repairs or cleaning that is necessary when they vacate the property. Our move-out process is extensive and includes a digital video recording of the property.

move-out process
property maintenance

Maintenance -

We have skilled, licensed and insured tradesmen and suppliers available to service your property's needs. With our purchasing power we get high quality service at reasonable rates. Our Vendors are loyal, trustworthy, and quick to respond. All receipts for services are provided with the owner’s statements. Emailed Communication updates of repairs and maintenance.

Setting High Standards -

When you put your property on the market in the best condition it can possibly be, you’re going to get a lot more interest from potential renters. You’re also setting a standard for how you expect the property to be maintained during the course of a lease. If you hand over a home that has scratched flooring, broken appliances and chipped paint, your tenants will get the idea that you don’t care very much about the home. They won’t care either. 

setting standards
owner statements

Financials and Reporting -

Detailed accounting for all income and expenses for your property is provided on a monthly basis. The timely disbursement of funds to owners is a high priority. We utilize the industry's most advanced property management and accounting program to accomplish this. This program also allows owners to access the system online and obtain property information through the online Owner Portal. Copies of all lease documents, accounting statements, work orders, receipts, and vendor invoices are stored and available for viewing in the Owner Portal at any time. At the end of the year we supply owners with annual statements categorizing all income and expenses for the property and a 1099-MISC for tax purposes. 

  • Q: Answers Regarding Funds

    A: When you entered into a management agreement, LEGENDS REALTY established an account for you and your property. LEGENDS REALTY recognizes the importance of accurately collecting and disbursing funds. The bookkeeping program used by LEGENDS REALTY is specialized software designed to handle the many facets of property management and accurate record keeping, and complies with the requirements of the Florida Real Estate Commission.
  • Q: Banking

    A: LEGENDS REALTY holds your account in a trust fund mandated by the state of Florida. This account does not earn interest. LEGENDS REALTY accounts for each owner’s funds separately in the trust account and does not co-mingle funds with broker monies, following the Florida Real Estate Commission requirements.
  • Q: Monthly statements

    A: LEGENDS REALTY sends monthly statements to owners via online owner portal. An email will be sent monthly as a reminder. If you have difficulty reading your monthly statement, please contact your management team. We are happy to assist you and answer your questions.
  • Q: Disbursement of monthly funds

    A: LEGENDS REALTY disburses available funds to owners on the 10th of each month UNLESS either day falls on a Saturday, Sunday or Holiday, in which case disbursements are processed on the following Tuesday. A calendar of scheduled payout process dates is available on our website LEGENDS REALTY does not disburse funds on weekends and holidays. LEGENDS REALTY does NOT issue owner checks unless there are sufficient funds in the owner’s account. It is vital to accurately post rents, pay vendors, and disburse funds for your account. Therefore, it is vital that LEGENDS REALTY adhere to this schedule to ensure servicing every owner’s account.
    LEGENDS REALTY distributes owner funds in two ways:
    • Company check disbursed directly to the owner accompanying their monthly statement.
    • ACH direct deposit – directly disbursed into an owner’s bank account; LEGENDS REALTY mails monthly statements after disbursement. A form to start ACH is included with this information.
  • Q:  End of year procedures

    A: At the end of each year, LEGENDS REALTY is required to file 1099’s for income received over $600. Please note that this amount is for “total income received,” and not the yearly total of owner disbursements. The Internal Revenue Service dictates the “total income received” requirement. Please note that security deposits are not included in this amount.
    It is necessary that you supply LEGENDS REALTY with the necessary Social Security/Tax ID information so the 1099 is accurate. LEGENDS REALTY will send the 1099 for the rent by January 31 for the previous tax year. If there is a change in your tax information such as a new trust or address, please notify us with the Owner Change of Information form. If you need another change form, please contact us.
    LEGENDS REALTY also issues 1099s for disbursements to vendors for work over $600.00. Therefore, owners do not have to issue 1099s for work completed and paid through the LEGENDS REALTY trust account. Owners are responsible for issuing 1099s to any vendor paid through the owner’s personal account.
    The last statement of the year will reflect “total amounts” for income and expenses that have transpired throughout the year, such as management fees, leasing fees, landscape, utilities, repairs and maintenance, etc. The amounts will not reflect any funds issued through the owners personal account. Owners can submit their last statement to their tax person along with other information for income tax reporting. LEGENDS REALTY does not issue statements to the owner’s tax preparers. Please note a copy of the owners 1099 and cash flow report will be available in the owners online portal.

Technology -

New Age Real Estate incorporates the most advanced technology available in the business:

  • Paperless Office
  • Electronic
  • Payments (ACH)
  • Electronic Rent Collection (ACH)
  • Industry Leading
  • Web Based Management and Accounting Program
  • Owner and Tenant Online
  • Web Portals
  • Online Document Signing and Storage
  • Electronic Statements and Reporting
  • Bank Lockbox Service
  • e-fax, VOIP phone system
  • Digital Video Recording Online & Website Advertising
  • Search Engine Placement

We are always looking for new innovations that will better serve our clients.

Licenced Realtors

Licensed REALTORS® -

A real estate agent who is a member of the National Association of REALTORS®, which means that he or she must uphold the standards of the association and its code of ethics.

Eviction Protection

Eviction Protection -

We pay for the cost of an eviction if the tenant we procured defaults on the payment of rent.

Rental Value

What will your home rent for? -

We will prepare a rental range for you; forward all the documents for your review then a Business Developer will call you to schedule a time to view your property. Click here Free Rental Analysis


Full Service Management Agreement: *recommended

Our monthly management fee is 8% or $100 whichever is greater of the collected and a one-time fee of 50% of contracted rent once we secure a tenant. The fee comes from the first collected rent.

Lease Only Agreement:

For local owners interested in managing their property, but need assistance in marketing and securing a qualified tenant.
There is a one-time fee of one full month’s rent once we secure a tenant for this service. The fee comes from the first collected rent.

***We offer a 20% discount to our Management Fees listed in our Agreement to Owners/Investors once we list four or more properties under one Tax ID or Social Security number using our Full Service Management Agreement.

Additional Professional Services such as Eviction Protection, detailed Bi-Annual Property Review Reports, direct deposit, initial lease preparation and so much more are offered with Full Management Only

Sample Marketing Videos

Casselberry Area Information

Prior to European settlement in the 19th-century Native American groups inhabited the Seminole County area, including land in present-day Casselberry. A blockhouse known as Fort Concord was constructed on the shores of Lake Concord in 1849 to protect local settlers during conflicts between the Seminole Wars.

After the Homestead Act was passed in 1862, settlers began homesteading the land around Lake Concord and the Triplet Chain of Lakes. Annie E. Griffin of Eastman, Georgia platted the area’s first subdivision in 1889 after inheriting the land from her deceased husband.

Despite the fact that Casselberry was an incorporated town and Fern Park remained unincorporated the United States Postal Service refused to grant Casselberry its own post office due to a policy prohibiting the naming of post offices after living persons. Casselberry established a contract post office in 1957 at its own expense and the town was finally granted a post office in 1959, although Hibbard Casselberry lived another ten years. The City of Casselberry was incorporated on July 25, 1965 and Casselberry’s citizens eventually voted to have property taxes in 1976. Casselberry’s first city hall was dedicated in 1970 and comprises part of the current municipal complex. Source From Wikipedia

Areas We Serve